top of page

Managing Risk, Building Confidence: Horrocks’ Alternative Delivery Experience

1 day ago
8 min read

Aerial view of a major spaghetti bowl freeway interchange

When an infrastructure project has tight constraints, significant risks, and complex constructability concerns, the delivery method matters as much as the design. Construction Manager/General Contractor (CMGC) and Construction Manager At-Risk (CMAR) bring a contractor onto the team early, working alongside the owner and designer to identify and mitigate risk before construction begins. As for other project delivery methods, Design-Build (DB) can shorten the delivery timeline, but it requires significant time to prepare contract documents and procure a DB team. Progressive Design-Build (PDB) sits between the two, developing the design and the construction contract at the same time. Each method has a place based on the project schedule, complexity, and risks. In some states, DB and/or PDB are not permitted. If this is the case, then CMGC stands out for keeping the project focused on the practical realities of construction. 


Built for Construction Feasibility


Construction work on a bridge over a river in a narrow canyon
Construction of the Manning Crevice Bridge - Crane Placement

CMGC incorporates a contractor’s knowledge into the design. Constructability reviews happen during design, so construction risks can be mitigated and constructability improved before construction starts. By resolving issues and mitigating risks before pricing, CMGC provides owners with cost certainty earlier in the process. For example, Horrocks used 3D models for the Manning Crevice Bridge in Idaho to evaluate crane positioning on the confined cliffside site and 4D models to illustrate each stage of construction. Additionally, during Phase 1 of the Mountain View Corridor in Utah, several innovative design solutions were developed during the CMGC process, including the use of lightweight fill to avoid costly utility relocations and optimization of the earthwork to minimize haul and costs.

 

Minimizing Construction Duration and Disruptions to the Traveling Public 


Early contractor involvement with CMGC can shorten the overall construction schedule. Once the team has sufficient confidence in the design, the contractor can begin procurement of long-lead items such as steel transmission poles, steel girders, and water valves, ensuring that obtaining these elements does not control the overall schedule. Additionally, other early work packages can be executed between the owner and contractor to speed up project delivery while design is completed. Early construction packages can include tree removal, clearing and grubbing, utility relocations, or other elements that provide advantages to the overall project schedule. This phased approach to a project allows construction to start while design progresses. Horrocks has used these practices on more than a dozen CMGC and CMAR projects to accelerate schedules.


A critical part of most highway projects is maintaining traffic and minimizing disruptions to the traveling public. Having a contractor on the team to work directly with the owner and designer allows the traffic control plans to be developed based on the owner’s requirements for lane closures and the contractor’s plan to build the project. This approach allows for efficient traffic control because the designer is not making assumptions as to how the contractor will build the project.  


Managing Risk and Transparent Pricing 


CMGC allows owners and contractors to jointly manage project risk. The contractor provides the owner with transparent pricing that shows how risk is included within the price. Risk allocation and transparent pricing help owners understand more than the final price. The owner may elect to hold money as contingency for a certain risk rather than having the contractor include the full amount in their price. A good example is soft spot repair of the subgrade, as neither the owner nor contractor know exactly how much repair will be needed until the existing roadway is removed. Together they decide on a reasonable contingency amount, but the owner only pays for the actual subgrade repair quantity. This approach benefits both parties without placing undue risk on either party.  A significant benefit of CMGC is the contractor’s understanding of the project and risks, which typically results in price confidence and fewer change orders and material overruns.


Horrocks’ CMGC Experience 


Horrocks has participated in more than a dozen CMGC or CMAR projects. As a program manager, designer, or independent quality firm, we have worked with state departments of transportation, state departments of corrections, international airport authorities, and federal agencies to deliver these projects throughout the West. 


Manning Crevice Bridge, Riggins, ID 


A bridge in a narrow canyon over a river
The Manning Crevice Bridge

Horrocks served as the roadway and retaining wall designer, local liaison, and CMGC delivery adviser for this replacement of a 1930s Civilian Conservation Corps bridge over the Salmon River in Idaho. Because of the remote site and steep canyon, Horrocks recommended CMGC so the designer and contractor could work together on innovation and risk management. The team used 3D and 4D models to plan the bridge’s construction step by step and to determine crane placement on a narrow cliffside site. Horrocks also helped Western Federal Lands Highway Division and Idaho County carry out their first CMGC project. This project won the 2019 ACEC Idaho Engineering Excellence Gold Award, the 2018 ASCE Southern Idaho Project of the Year Award, the 2019 ENR Mountain States Best Project Award, and the 2020 AISA National Steel Bridge Alliance Bridge Award.


Southern Parkway (SR-7), Washington County, UT


A photo of an interchange in southern Utah
Southern Parkway (SR-7)

Southern Parkway (SR-7) is a 26-mile, limited-access regional transportation corridor connecting I-15 at Exit 2 near Sun River in St. George to SR-9 near 2800 West in Hurricane. Open to traffic along its full length, the parkway serves as an eastern belt route for Washington County, providing access to St. George, Washington, and Hurricane and an alternative route to I-15. The corridor has at least one travel lane in each direction and is planned for phased expansion to a four-lane divided expressway as traffic demand and funding warrant.


Horrocks designed approximately 20 miles of the corridor, including nine new interchanges, wash realignments, a spillway at the Stucki Debris Basin Dam, multiple large culverts with headwalls, pavement, signing, striping, right-of-way, and Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) reevaluations. The contractor, through the CMGC partnership, provided input and assisted in mitigating risk for those design elements. In addition, they helped determine that installing a re-use water line alongside the road was the most cost-effective solution for construction water, and the contractor helped with sequencing the work and deciding the overall schedule.


Dixie Drive Interchange, St. George, UT


An aerial view late in the afternoon of an interchange in southern Utah
The Dixie Drive Interchange in St. George, UT

The Dixie Drive Interchange project began as an innovative way to relieve congestion at the Bluff Street Interchange, a bottleneck on I-15 in St. George, Utah. Because the new interchange sat close to the existing Bluff Street Interchange, the two were connected by one-way collector/distributor roads to address weaving and merging concerns on I-15. Horrocks completed the initial corridor study, environmental assessment, and subsequent design for this CMGC project, which added a single-point urban interchange (SPUI) with a seven-lane arterial for Dixie Drive. Traffic simulation models guided the lane and storage requirements of the arterial design. The project also included 31 structures, six of them bridges.


Mountain View Corridor, Utah and Salt Lake Counties, UT


Aerial view of a freeway system with neighborhoods and mountains in the distance
Mountain View Corridor

Horrocks was the design manager, intelligent transportation system (ITS) lead designer, and utilities lead designer for the entire corridor as part of the design team. Phase 1 of the project, which included new roadway from the Porter Rockwell Boulevard/Redwood Road intersection up to the intersection with 5400 South, was delivered using CMGC to help develop innovative solutions that maximize the amount of new roadway built. Horrocks also led design for the southern segment, from SR-73 in Lehi to Juniper Canyon in Saratoga Springs. At full build-out, the 35-mile, eight-lane freeway will connect I-80 in Salt Lake City with I-15 in Lehi.


Horrocks’ PDB Experience


Not every project is a fit for CMGC. Some of the most demanding projects benefit from PDB, which brings the owner, designer, and builder together early and lets the design and construction contract advance at the same time. When a project’s challenges call for both speed and a tightly coordinated team, PDB can deliver results that are hard to achieve any other way. Horrocks was the lead designer for the first PDB project in Utah.


US-89; Farmington to I-84 South, Davis County, UT


Aerial view of an expressway system
US-89; Farmington to I-84 South

Horrocks served as lead designer for the team on this project in northern Utah, which converted 12 miles of US-89 from a four-lane highway into a six-lane, grade-separated expressway. The project won the 2023 Utah Construction & Design Highway Project of the Year and the 2024 ACEC Utah and National Grand Award in Transportation.



I-15; 5600 South, Weber County, UT


Interchange on a major freeway
I-15; 5600 South

Horrocks served as the lead designer for this interchange reconstruction and widening project, delivered through the PDB method, which reduced congestion and improved safety along I-15 in Weber County, Utah. It included a new SPUI and the widening of 5600 South from I-15 to 3500 West. Horrocks, along with a geotechnical subconsultant, worked with the Utah Department of Transportation (UDOT) to support a new pedestrian bridge using continuous flight auger piles. This was the first use of this foundation system on a UDOT project. This reduced vibration and noise impacts to nearby homes and apartments during installation. The PDB delivery methodology was critical to team collaboration to implement this innovation.


SR 167, I-5 to SR 161 – New Expressway Project, Pierce County, WA


Horrocks teamed on the SR 167, I-5 to SR 161 – New Expressway Project, the Washington State Department of Transportation’s (WSDOT) first major highway PDB project. Located in Pierce County, Washington, and within the Puyallup Tribe of Indians reservation boundary, the project is part of the Puget Sound Gateway Program and will create new connections to I-5 and the Port of Tacoma. The project includes regional trail connections, local road and intersection improvements, seven new bridges, and approximately 90 acres of stream and wetland habitat restoration. Horrocks is currently designing two new bridge structures over the stream, one carrying Tacoma Rail and another a local roadway, to eliminate existing fish-passage barriers and restore stream connectivity.


Our Experts


Matt Horrocks, PE


Matt Horrocks

Matt is a Principal Engineer and Sr. Project Manager, bringing more than 24 years of experience designing and managing transportation projects. His experience includes design leadership on UDOT’s US-89 and 5600 South PDB projects; senior advisory on SR 167, I-5 to SR 161 – New Expressway Project and Frontrunner PDBs; and serving as Segment 1 Lead Engineer for Mountain View Corridor CMGC and Roadway Design Lead for the I-80, State Street to 1300 East CMGC project. Matt brings value to any project he joins, implementing innovative design, best-value solutions, and proactive risk management. He has led projects with unique design challenges and accelerated schedules. Matt strives to implement his knowledge and expertise in developing innovative ideas and solutions to address project challenges and issues and has done so for more than a dozen departments of transportation.



Richard Hansen, PE, SE


Richard Hansen

Richard brings more than 20 years of experience delivering complex transportation projects, with extensive leadership experience in CMGC, DB, and PDB. He has served in management and lead roles on 18 CMGC and DB projects, with PDB experience that includes Design Manager/Structures Manager for UDOT’s I-15/5600 South Widening and Structures Design Manager for US-89, Farmington to I-84. Richard works closely with owners, contractors, and multidisciplinary teams to improve constructability, manage risk, and develop practical design solutions. On US-89, his innovative bridge design avoided relocating more than 3,000 feet of petroleum pipeline, saving $2.1 million and months of impacts.



Jake Menard, PE, SE


Jake Menard

Jake brings 25 years of experience delivering multidisciplinary transportation projects using traditional, DB, and PDB delivery methods. His experience spans structural design, construction engineering, and owner support for WSDOT and Idaho Transportation Department (ITD) DB procurement and execution. He is currently leading the SR 167, I-5 to SR 161 – New Expressway Project PDB, guiding multidisciplinary coordination and collaboration with the owner and contractor team. On WSDOT’s $350 million SR 520 Eastside Transit and high-occupancy vehicle (HOV) DB project, he led structural engineers through design and construction support for bridges, lid structures, and other complex infrastructure. Jake brings a collaborative approach to resolving design challenges, improving constructability, and reducing construction risk.



Kelly Hoopes, PE


Kelly Hoopes

Kelly is a Principal Engineer and Senior Project Manager with more than 20 years of ITD project experience, having worked on over 65 ITD and Local Highway Technical Assistance Council (LHTAC) projects. He has served as project manager for more than 15 major ITD projects and currently serves as Deputy Project Manager for the I-15/US-20 Connector, one of eastern Idaho’s largest and most complex transportation planning and environmental projects. His design work covers interchanges, roundabouts, and urban and rural roadways, including the US-20 interchange studies that led to future diverging diamond interchange (DDI) projects in Rexburg. He also led the roadway design for the Manning Crevice Bridge CMGC project in Idaho.


Work With Horrocks


Open communication, innovation, and flexibility among owner, designer, and builder lead to faster delivery, cost-effective solutions, and projects that better serve the community. To learn how our team can support your CMGC or PDB project, let us know through our contact page.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page